Screening and Assessment of Co-Occurring Disorders

Dual diagnoses are common. Approximately half of people struggling with addiction also have a co-occurring mental health disorder at some point in their lives, and vice versa.² It’s not always easy to understand which disorder manifested first, and one disorder doesn’t always directly lead to the other. Sometimes, people with addictions may develop a mental health disorder due to substance use in and of itself. However, people with mental health disorders may self-medicate their symptoms with substances to find relief, which can influence the development of a substance use disorder.²

Different terms are sometimes used to refer to a dual diagnosis, but all of these terms refer to the same phenomenon. You may hear the terms comorbidity, dual pathology, co-occurring conditions, or co-occurring disorders when people talk about a dual diagnosis.

The terms comorbid or co-occurring simply mean disorders that occur together. Sometimes these terms are also used to refer to the presence of physical health disorders, (for example, a stimulant use disorder with co-occurring heart disease or high blood pressure).³

However, the term dual diagnosis isn’t typically used by clinicians to refer to co-occurring addiction and physical health issues.⁴ They are more often used to refer to co-occurring addiction and another psychiatric illness.^2,5

Statistics on Mental Health & Substance Use Disorders

According to the 2019 National Survey on Drug Use and Health, 3.8% of adults over the age of 18, or 9.5 million people, had any co-occurring any mental, behavioral, or emotional disorder (AMI) and SUD, such as anxiety or depression.⁶

Around 1.4% of adults, or 3.6 million people, had a serious mental illness (SMI) and SUD.⁶ An SMI is a diagnosable disorder that seriously impacts a person’s functioning. This includes disorders like major depression, schizophrenia, and bipolar disorder, as well as other DSM disorders that cause significant impairment to a person’s functioning and well-being.³

Treatment is important to address both disorders. Unfortunately, many people with dual diagnoses don’t get the help they need. According to the National Institute on Drug Abuse (NIDA), 52.5% of people with dual diagnosis didn’t receive any treatment, 34.5% received only mental health care, 9.1% received both mental health and substance abuse treatment, and 3.9% received substance treatment alone.⁷

How Are Co-Occurring Disorders Diagnosed & Assessed?

Co-occurring disorders are diagnosed through screening and multi-level assessments that seek to understand a person through various perspectives relevant to their symptoms and service needs. This comprehensive evaluation typically takes into account a person’s entire physical and mental health history in chronological order, as well as their history of substance abuse, previous substance abuse treatment, periods of extended abstinence, and relapses. Additional information is collected on a person’s strengths, limitations, skill deficits, and cultural barriers related to following a recommended treatment regimen for substance use disorders or mental health conditions.⁸

Screening patients is a necessary first step that ensures patients at a substance abuse treatment facility receive a full and correct diagnosis (or diagnoses if the patient has co-occurring disorders), and therefore the correct treatment regimen.⁸

Sometimes screenings are conducted to determine whether additional, more specific assessments will be necessary, such as one that’s designed to pinpoint whether or not a patient has a specific mental health condition.

People who enter treatment for mental illness must be screened for substance use disorders and should also be screened for mental illness. However, it can be difficult to diagnose co-occurring disorders, because symptoms of various mental health conditions and substance use disorders often overlap. Comprehensive assessment tools aid in the diagnostic process.³

Sometimes there are factors that can hinder a diagnosis and prompt treatment providers to re-screen or perform additional assessments. For example, people who are going through substance withdrawal can present with certain psychiatric symptoms that point to a co-occurring disorder (e.g., depression). When this happens, a patient will and intermittently as they progress in their treatment. In addition, a patient who was misusing multiple substances may cause more complications in diagnosis and treatment.³ 

Assessment Tools for Co-Occurring Disorders

Though each provider may use different dual diagnosis assessments, some tools used in the assessment, screening, and diagnosis of substance use disorders and co-occurring mental health conditions may include:⁹

• Addiction Severity Index (ASI).
• Alcohol Use Disorder Identification Test.
• Mental Health Screening Form III.
• Columbia-Suicide Severity Rating Scale.
• Michigan Alcoholism Screening Test.
• The Stages of Change Readiness and Treatment Eagerness Scale.
• The University of Rhode Island Change and Assessment Scale.
• Drug Use Disorder Identification Test.
• Psychiatric Research Interview for Substance and Mental Disorders (PRISM).
• Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-V (SCID-5).
• Symptom Checklist-90-Revised.
• Inventory of Depressive Symptoms.
• Montgomery Asberg Depression Rating Scale.
• Young Mania Rating Scale.
• Angst Hypomania Check List.

Can Rehab Treat My Addiction & Mental Health Issues?

Many outpatient and inpatient rehabs are able to treat co-occurring disorders. Research has shown that integrated co-occurring disorder treatment treatment that addresses symptoms of both disorders is superior to treating each disorder separately. Integrated treatment can involve a combination of therapies, such as cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT), motivational, and functional approaches.³ If you are interested in co-occurring disorder treatment, you should know that help is available, and your insurance may cover all or part of the cost of integrated treatment.

Take Our Self Assessment

Insurance Coverage for Co-Occurring Disorder Treatment

If you’re wondering whether your health insurance may cover dual diagnosis treatment at an American Addiction Centers rehab near you, simply fill out the form below with the required information and an AAC admissions navigator will reach out to you shortly with your treatment options.